• Industry
    • Opinion
    • Features
      • iGaming Data
      • Sports Betting Data
    • Finance
    • Online Casinos
    • Podcast

      News

      Ninth Circuit Court Upholds Tribal Sovereignty In Washington Gaming Dispute

      The decision comes as tribes in different states continue to receive stronger support for their gambling initiatives

      By Erik Gibbs

      Last updated: December 19, 2024

      2 min

      washington state flag

      The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals recently unanimously upheld a lower court decision to dismiss a lawsuit brought by cardroom operator Maverick Gaming. The case sought to challenge the gaming compacts between Washington state and its federally recognized tribes, a move that could have disrupted the carefully negotiated agreements that govern tribal gaming.

      The lawsuit aimed to invalidate the compacts negotiated between Washington tribes and the state, agreements that were approved by the federal government. Notably, the tribes themselves were not included as parties to the lawsuit, meaning any decision on the compacts’ validity would have occurred without tribal participation.

      This procedural omission played a pivotal role in the court’s dismissal.

      Maverick Gaming’s broader objective is to dismantle Washington’s state law that restricts sports betting to tribal casinos. Passed by a bipartisan supermajority in the state legislature, the law reflects Washington’s longstanding policy of supporting regulated governmental gaming, such as tribal gaming and the state lottery, while limiting private entities’ ability to profit from gambling.

      The law was later incorporated into the gaming compacts negotiated with tribes, solidifying their exclusive rights to operate sports betting within their brick-and-mortar casino facilities.

      The Ninth Circuit Court’s panel highlighted that Maverick’s desired outcome conflicted with Washington’s well-established policy on gambling regulation. The court also emphasized the broader implications of the lawsuit on tribal sovereignty, particularly the economic and legal protections provided by the gaming compacts.

      A victory for tribal governments

      The ruling is a strong reminder of the role gaming plays in supporting tribal governments and communities. By generating revenue under the compacts, tribal casinos fund essential government services for tribal citizens and reservation residents.

      The Ninth Circuit concluded that Maverick’s lawsuit could not proceed “in equity and good conscience” without the tribes’ involvement, as it implicated “legally protected economic and sovereign interests” central to the tribes’ self-determination.

      The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the dismissal of Maverick Gaming LLC’s lawsuit in Maverick Gaming LLC v. United States, which sought to challenge Washington State’s tribal-state compacts that allowed sports betting on tribal lands. https://t.co/0D0OVfS9KG pic.twitter.com/dEluxXmOnV

      — Snell & Wilmer (@SWLawNews) December 17, 2024

      Washington Indian Gaming Association Executive Director Rebecca George welcomed the ruling, viewing it as a reaffirmation of tribal sovereignty. She noted that the unanimous decision marked the fourth federal judge to rule against Maverick Gaming’s efforts to undermine the tribal-state gaming compacts.

      “Washington tribes are sovereign nations,” George said in a statement. “The gaming compacts are carefully negotiated, government to government agreements that are fully valid and legally binding. The Washington state legislature’s bipartisan supermajority decision to limit sports betting to the premises of tribal casinos is not only legally sound, it also strikes exactly the right balance, allowing responsible adults to participate in safe and well-regulated gaming activities while minimizing the negative social consequences that can sometimes result from gambling.”

      George also expressed confidence in the legal foundation of the compacts and the tribes’ ability to continue defending its rights against Maverick Gaming’s challenges.

      A legal battle far from over

      Despite this legal victory, the fight is expected to continue. Maverick Gaming has indicated its intent to persist with its efforts to challenge the compacts and the broader framework of tribal gaming regulation.

      Still, tribal leaders and advocates remain steadfast in their commitment to defending the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act and preserving the sovereignty of Washington’s tribes.

      Get Weekly Email Updates

      Covering all aspects of regulated U.S. online casinos, iGaming, sweepstakes, and more

      Related Posts

      celtics court

      Massachusetts Requests Detailed Data From Operators On Sports Bettor Limiting

      golden nugget atlantic city

      DraftKings To Close Live Dealer Studio At Golden Nugget, Let Go 101 Employees

      step away

      Joe Brennan Jr. Stepping Away From Prime Sports

      michigan flag money

      Michigan Online Gaming Revenue Drops In April Compared To Record March, But Still Strong

      Recommended Read

      washington state casinos online ruling

      News

      Washington State Rules Against Social Casinos In Gambling Suit

      There’s More…

      jake elliott kick

      News

      Illinois Gaming Board Bans Series Of Conduct-Related NFL Wagers

      February 7, 2025

      Chris Altruda

      card shuffle

      News

      PENN Partners With Light & Wonder For Branded Live Dealer Games In Michigan

      September 9, 2024

      Erik Gibbs

      super bowl lix

      News

      Narrowing Focus To Regulated Wagering, AGA Estimates Record Amount Bet On Super Bowl LIX

      February 4, 2025

      Eric Raskin

      texas flag

      News

      Deja Daily: Texas Lawmakers Attempt To Legalize DFS Again

      March 17, 2025

      Jeff Edelstein

      Get Weekly Email Updates

      Covering all aspects of regulated U.S. online casinos, iGaming, sweepstakes, and more

      • About
      • Contact
      • Privacy
      • Terms
      • Disclosure
      • Responsible Gaming

      © 2025 Casino Reports. Web Design by Fhoke.